双阶理论视域下可再生能源绿色电力证书的法律属性研究

Research on the Legal Attributes of Green Power Certificates for Renewable Energy from the Perspective of Two-order Theory

  • 摘要: 借用德国的双阶理论对绿证进行双阶构造,绿证的全生命周期管理可以划分为两个不同的法律关系。建档立卡和核发等绿证第一阶段的行为具有行政许可、行政确认的公法属性,绿证交易和核销等第二阶段的行为体现为以私法调整为主、兼具公权力介入的复合属性,两阶段划分的时间节点在于绿证的核发完成。绿证双阶构造的特殊性体现在第二阶段具有公权力介入之性质:一方面绿证交易阶段在规则制定、市场监管等公权力多面介入;另一方面,绿证的核销阶段融入行政确认行为,将绿证双阶构造的第二阶段修正为“民事合同+行政行为”的模式。通过分析绿证市场公权力介入的正当性、合法性和介入限度,提出相关完善建议。

     

    Abstract: By applying Germany's two-stage theory to the construction of green certificates, the entire lifecycle management of green certificates can be divided into two distinct legal relationships. The first stage—covering registration and issuance—possesses public law characteristics such as administrative licensing and administrative confirmation. The second stage, involving trading and cancellation of green certificates, exhibits a hybrid nature primarily governed by private law but also incorporating elements of public authority intervention. The dividing point between these two stages lies in the completion of certificate issuance. The uniqueness of this two-stage framework lies in the involvement of public authority in the second stage: on one hand, public power intervenes extensively during the trading phase through rule-making and market supervision; on the other hand, the cancellation phase incorporates administrative confirmation, transforming the second stage into a model combining "civil contract" with "administrative action." By analyzing the legitimacy, legality, and extent of public authority intervention in the green certificate market, this paper proposes relevant recommendations for improvement.

     

/

返回文章
返回